Hand-tossed pizzas and homemade sauces, let our family cook for you.

Hot Subs & Sandwiches


All subs served on Ithaca Bakery French bread. Sandwiches available on half a sub roll or a round roll
  Sandwiches Sub
Chicken Parmesan SubClassic Chicken Parmesan
6.00 9.00
Eggplant Parmesan Sub – Classic Eggplant Parmesan 5.75 8.75
ICO Meatball Parm - Our classic Parmesan sub with our Nana’s homemade meatballs 6.25 9.50
Veal ParmFreshly pounded and breaded veal, sauce & mozzarella cheese N/A 10.00
Chicken TenderBreaded chicken strips served with mayo, lettuce and tomato 5.75 8.50
Chicken WingBreaded chicken strips tossed in your choice of wing sauce with our homemade blue cheese dressing 6.25 8.75
Beef Philly Cheese SteakBeef cheese steak with green peppers, onions & American cheese N/A 9.15
Sausage, Peppers & OnionsGrilled hot sausage patties topped with peppers and onions
6.25 8.80
HamburgerBlack Angus hamburger served on a roll with your choice of fixings 6.50 8.25
Tullyburger – Black Angus cheeseburger served lettuce, tomato, onions & mayo 7.50 9.75
Grilled Chicken – Marinated grilled chicken with mayo, lettuce & tomato 6.50 9.25
Fish – Fried Fish on a roll served with tartar sauce 7.00 10.00
Something Special: Not available in sandwich size Subs Only
Flying SquirrelOur classic chicken wing sub with Philly cheese steak 9.80
Chicken Supreme - Breaded chicken strips on a roll with 1,000 Island dressing & grilled ham & swiss 9.50
Beef ItalianoBeef, melted provolone, mayo, lettuce and tomato on garlic bread  9.50
Chicken Ranch - Breaded chicken strips tossed in our Hot BBQ sauce, with ranch, Swiss and a few breaded onions
Web Exclusive! 9.50
Chicken Bacon Ranch -  Breaded chicken strips, ranch dressing, Swiss cheese and bacon 9.50
Hot Sicilian - Italian mix toasted with spicy mustard roasted reds, green peppers and onions Web Exclusive! 9.00
Pizzaburger – Grilled hot Italian sausage patties, topped with melted mozzarella & our Nana’s spaghetti sauce 9.25
Only available as a sandwich Not available as a full sub
ICO Burger - A burger made from our Nana’s Meatball recipe with lettuce, tomato, mozzarella cheese & a few breaded onions 6.00
ICO Hot Dog - Our famous hotdog with cream cheese, relish, mustard, ketchup and American cheese 4.25
Sub Extras
****Add Green peppers, grilled onions, mushrooms or banana peppers to any sub. Add one or all 1.00
Extra Chicken (Breaded or Grilled) 2.15 2.75
Extra Cheese 1.00 1.50
Add Bacon 1.25 1.85
Garlic Sub Roll 0.70 1.00
  • Free Delivery